Note
For decades, Democratic candidates for House and Senate have allied with Republicans in supporting unconditional military aid to Israel. They have attacked the international judiciary and human rights organizations trying to hold Israel accountable, opposed the United Nations from taking leadership in resolving the conflict, opposed any kind of Palestinian statehood outside of what Israel would voluntarily agree to, and attacked those campaigning in support of Palestinian rights.
This has finally started to change. Polls now show that a majority of voters, including an overwhelming majority of Democrats, believe the United States should stop providing the Israeli government with a blank check. Unfortunately, most of the traditional Democratic consultants advising nominees have not gotten the memo and continue to advise taking a more conventional approach.
This briefing paper is designed for Democratic House and Senate nominees which examines the key issues and major hot button issues regarding U.S. policy and Israel/Palestine. It includes suggestions on how to address them in a way that is principled and consistent with the views of most Democratic voters (particularly on the progressive end), yet avoids some of the traps that could lead to a backlash from Republicans and hawkish Democrats.
Even if you aren’t running for office, you might find it helpful in sorting out your own thinking on what the US should do regarding Israel/Palestine.
If you know any Democratic nominees or anyone in leadership of the campaigns, please pass this on to them. It’s rather long, but you can quickly skim the brief talking points and delve into any details that intrigue you.
—Stephen
Part I
The U.S. & Israel:
Resolving the Democratic Party’s Dilemma
The gist: No country, including Israel, should be unfairly accused or unfairly exempted from accountability. Polls suggest voters are adopting this view in increasing numbers, creating important ramifications for Democratic candidates.
Every candidate has to craft talking points that reflect their positions in their voice. What follows can either be lifted word for word or taken as suggestions for clarifying your own positions.
You are likely familiar with the dilemma that you—and many candidates in the Democratic Party running for office, or candidates you are working for—must navigate. On the one hand, recent history has arguably demonstrated that support for arming and otherwise defending the Israeli government has been a factor in some Democratic candidates losing elections, including possibly the presidential race of 2024. On the other, taking a strong anti-Israel stance risks losing some swing voters.
For many progressives, particularly younger voters, a candidate’s willingness to oppose U.S. support for Israel can be decisive in determining whether they will support a Democratic candidate or instead stay home or vote third party. As with an earlier generation during the Vietnam War, the Israeli-Palestinian question is seen by many as more than just a single policy disagreement; for them it’s a fundamental moral issue which can determine how they vote.
It is easy to critique those who would refuse to support any pro-Israel Democrat in the face of the Republican threat, but nevertheless, such steadfast refusal has real consequences come election time. And, even among those who intend to vote Democratic, having a nominee refuse to take a principled stand could diminish their enthusiasm for participating in get out the vote drives and other important campaign support.
Despite local variations, not only are there strong moral imperatives for challenging U.S. support for the Israeli government, but opposing Israel’s actions and U.S. support for them mostly improves the chances of Democratic victories. Polls show a solid majority of Americans now have an unfavorable view of Israel and oppose military aid. Just as importantly, these views are not static; the public’s support for Israel continues to deteriorate.
At the same time, due to the special sensitivity of the issue, particularly regarding antisemitism, there are swing voters who could be alienated if a Democratic nominee takes positions that are convincingly depicted as too anti-Israel, or even antisemitic.
Here are twelve talking points segmented into topics and terms designed to stay true to our values while threading the needle.
Part II
Five Topics & Talking Points on U.S./Israel
Holding fast to principle while maximizing political advantage
Overview
These sections use a consistent format:
Headline: Topic or term
Talking point
Backlash claim
Our response
Analysis
Topics—five aspects of U.S. policy towards Israel/Palestine about which candidates could stake positions.
Talking points which could be considered by the candidate.
Backlash claims are what Democratic candidates are likely to encounter either before or after the position is announced.
Our response contains suggestions of how to handle the backlash/opposing position/ accusations hurled at candidates who take these positions.
Analysis contains additional details fleshing out the talking points and why it makes sense, sometimes including polling data showing how the position lines up with voters.
Topic 1: Is criticism of Israel Antisemitic?
Talking point 1: Israeli Jews fully deserve peace and security, and the United States could be a guarantor of that right, but Washington must not continue to provide a blank check for a far-right Israeli government engaging in illegal, immoral, racist, and self-destructive policies. The U.S. must apply this standard to every state.
Backlash claim: Anything short of unqualified support for Israel is antisemitic.
Our response: Defending Hamas terrorism, exaggerating Zionist influence in U.S. politics, or demanding higher standards for Israel than other countries could reasonably be seen as antisemitic. However, Israel, no more or less than any other country, should be bound by universal standards of human rights and international law, including the illegality of targeting civilians during war or expanding territory by force. For example, one can oppose Russia’s actions in Ukraine without being bigoted towards those of the Russian Orthodox faith.
Analysis: In many respects, the debate over U.S. support for Israel parallels those regarding U.S. support for other far rightwing governments engaging in war crimes and other violations of human rights and international law. As with U.S. support for allied regimes and paramilitary groups in Central America in the 1980s, the U.S. government today is similarly denying the extent of the abuses, attacking human rights organizations and the international judiciary for alleged bias, and accusing opponents of U.S. policy of nefarious ideological motivations. The difference is that, as the world’s only Jewish state, there are a fair number of otherwise liberal and moderate Democrats who side with Republicans in making such accusations of antisemitism. It is important to make criticisms of U.S. support for the Israeli government explicitly part of just one component of an overall platform opposing U.S. support for any and all governments that violate such international norms. While it would indeed be wrong to unfairly single out Israel for criticism, it would also be wrong to unfairly exonerate or excuse Israel for policies that would be unacceptable from any other country.
Topic 2: Israel/Palestine as an issue of international humanitarian law
Talking point 2: Israeli violations of international humanitarian law are well-documented. It is important to defend the International Criminal Court (ICC), the International Court of Justice (ICJ), and reputable Israeli and international human rights investigators for their willingness to document and seek accountability for violations of international humanitarian law regardless of the perpetrator.
Backlash claim: Allegations of Israeli violations are not credible. The ICC, the ICJ, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and other groups unfairly singling out Israel and their investigations therefore lack merit.
Our response: Condemnation of war crimes and holdings those guilty accountable must indeed be universal, but it is the critics who are biased. The myth that Israel is being unfairly singled out by the ICC is undermined by the fact that only two of the ICC’s 73 indictments have been against Israelis and they also targeted Hamas leaders. Similarly, rulings by the International Court of Justice regarding the Israeli occupation parallel earlier rulings regarding Morocco’s occupation of Western Sahara and apartheid South Africa’s earlier occupation of Namibia.
Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and other reputable human rights criticize any and all human rights abuses regardless of a country’s relations with the United States. Hamas, Hezbollah, Syria, and other countries and armed groups have been credibly accused of war crimes by these same organizations as well. No empirical survey or impartial investigation has ever found any evidence that these groups’ methodology, standards of evidence, or reporting is any tougher regarding Israel than on any other country. No country, including Israel, should be unfairly accused or unfairly exempted from accountability. Condemnation of war crimes and calls for accountability must be universal.
Accusations of Israeli war crimes and other human rights abuses do not just come from international bodies. Israeli violations of human rights, including international humanitarian law, have come from such Israeli groups as B’Tselem (the country’s leading human rights organization) and the veterans’ group Breaking the Silence, as well as Israeli journalists and documentarians. Accusing Israel of well-documented war crimes is based on the facts.
Analysis: The Republican Party’s position has put it at odds with most voters who believe in international humanitarian law and support such international legal institutions. Polls indicate that most voters vehemently oppose Israeli violations of international humanitarian law and other human rights abuses. By undermining the credibility of international legal institutions, prominent international jurists, and reputable human rights organizations, these attacks are not simply a defense of the Israeli government, but part of an effort to undermine international humanitarian law as a whole. (Republicans made similar false allegations following reports by human rights groups and a ruling by the ICJ involving violations by far-right U.S. allies in Central America during the 1980s.) Republican efforts to sanction human rights investigators and others seeking to uphold international humanitarian law are nothing less than a campaign to give war criminals impunity. Further, the effort undermines the basic post-WWII legal standards which the United States has traditionally, if unevenly, defended for more than 75 years.
Topic 3: Opposing arms transfers to Israel (and other countries in the region)
Talking point 3: Oppose military aid to Israel as part of a call for an arms moratorium for the entire Middle East.
Backlash claim: Israel has a lot of enemies and needs our military support.
Our response: Israel does not need more U.S. aid for its defense. It has by far the most powerful armed forces in the region and has sufficient deterrent capabilities, including a nuclear deterrent, to defend against any realistic possible combination of enemies.
The 1997 Leahy Law restricts U.S. support for countries engaged in illegal activities using U.S. weapons. Similarly, Israel is in clear violation of Section 502B(c) of the 1961 Foreign Assistance Act, which prohibits aid to countries that prevent access to humanitarian relief supplies. Continued failure to enforce these important laws regarding Israel weakens them overall, thereby giving the Trump administration and future administrations license to arm other war criminals as well.
The Leahy Law applies to all U.S.-backed governments which have engaged in war crimes (i.e., Saudi Arabia, UAE, Turkey, Azerbaijan) in recent years, so it is important to be clear not to be singling out Israel in this regard. Indeed, in light of human rights abuses by virtually every Middle Eastern recipient of U.S. arms and the over-militarization of the region, a sound position a candidate could take would be to call for working with other arms exporters to impose an arms moratorium on the entire Middle East.
Analysis: Polls show close to 55% of Americans, including nearly 78% of registered Democrats, oppose military aid to Israel. If opposing all military aid seems politically difficult, it is important to at least come out against any additional offensive military aid and other arms transfers to Israel. It could also be easier to oppose military aid to Israel if you set a condition, such as requiring the withdrawal of Israeli forces from territories outside of Israel’s internationally recognized borders before military aid can resume.
Some argue it is wrong for Israel—with its universal healthcare, affordable higher education, and other benefits denied most Americans—to receive so many billions of dollars’ worth of U.S. taxpayers’ money. While this populist appeal is not without some merit, 80% of U.S. “aid to Israel” goes directly to U.S. arms manufacturers, not the Israeli treasury. So, to avoid encouraging isolationists and antisemites, the emphasis should be more on the ways in which our aid is enabling war crimes and other human rights abuses.
Topic 4: Ending the occupation and opposing territorial expansion
Talking point 4: It is time for Israel to withdraw from the West Bank and Gaza. The occupation must end.
Backlash claim: The Palestinians and other Arab governments states must first formally recognize Israel and provide security guarantees. And terrorist groups like Hamas and Hezbollah must first be eliminated. Until then, ever-expanding buffer zones are necessary for Israel’s security. (Or, a more extreme version advocated by some Republican nominees is that Israel has a Biblical right to all the lands it has conquered.)
Our response: The Palestinian government and five other Arab states have already formally recognized Israel with security guarantees and the remaining Arab states have pledged to do so as well in return for an end of the Israeli occupation. The Arab states have thereby fulfilled the “land for peace” criteria in UN Security Council resolutions, which the U.S long insisted was the basis of any peace settlement, mandating an Israeli withdrawal.
The Republicans and many Democrats have reinterpreted “land for peace” to mean somehow requiring guaranteeing the security of every Israeli from violence of any kind by any extremist group, such as Hamas and Hezbollah, before Israel withdraws. However, the emergence of Hezbollah and Hamas were direct reactions to Israeli occupations. Ending the occupations would diminish their threat. Furthermore, that position would be as unreasonable as the converse: Imagine if Arab armies demanded parts of Israel unless they could guarantee the security of every Palestinian from violence by Israelis.
Analysis: International law clearly prohibits the expansion of territory by force. For candidates, this raises three different issues.
1) Israel should return what it has taken by force;
2) The US should apply the principle that land taken by force must be returned universally; and
3) When the US applies the principle selectively rather than universally, it weakens our case when we seek international support to apply it.
Let’s look at each of these in turn:
First, the international prohibition of the expansion of territory by force requires Israel to withdraw from territories seized in 1967 and subsequently.
The colonization of conquered lands has long been recognized as illegitimate. Israel has moved over 750,000 settlers into the East Jerusalem and the West Bank in violation of Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention prohibiting the transfer of civilians onto territories under foreign belligerent occupation and its application to the Israeli-occupied territories has been confirmed by no less than five UN Security Council resolutions as well as the ICJ.
The ICJ has ruled that the occupation and colonization of the West Bank and East Jerusalem is illegal. And Israel can easily defend itself within its internationally recognized borders. Indeed, this would make Israel far more defensible than the current archipelago of illegal settlements and military outposts that have been built amidst a hostile population. (The October 7 terrorist attack was made possible in part by Netanyahu’s decision to redeploy forces guarding the border with Gaza to enforce the occupation and colonization of the occupied West Bank.)
In addition to the West Bank and the Golan Heights, during the past two years the Israelis have extended their occupation to control roughly 20% of Lebanon, 70% of Gaza, and additional parts of Syria. Any candidate serious about international law must demand a withdrawal from these territories as well.
Second, the principle of prohibiting expansion has been applied selectively by U.S. administrations. We should call for its universal application, in keeping with the position that such a fundamental principle of international law, enshrined in the United Nations Charter, must be enforced uniformly regardless of the violator’s relations with the United States.
The principle was repeatedly underscored by President Biden in response to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and its annexation of Crimea and much of the Donbas region. In contrast, the Trump administration recognized the Golan Heights as Israeli territory during its first term and the Biden administration refused to rescind it, and has effectively recognized Israel’s annexation of East Jerusalem and de facto annexation of large swathe
This principle also applies to other states as well, such as Morocco’s illegal occupation, annexation, and colonization of the nation of Western Sahara, which is a full member state of the African Union. Unfortunately, the Trump administration formally recognized the annexation at the end of his first term and Biden similarly failed to reverse it.
The United States did not always support such illegal expansionism. Under the Reagan administration, the United States supported the United Nations Security Council when it declared the 1981 Israeli annexation of the Golan “null and void.” For decades, the United States also supported the United Nations’ demand for the right of Western Sahara to self-determination. Unfortunately, the United States has subsequently reversed these policies, becoming virtually the only country in the world to have formally recognized these two illegal takeovers.
It would be important, therefore, to call for rescinding both U.S. recognition of Israel’s annexation of the Golan as well as Morocco’s occupation of Western Sahara, noting how they undermine the post-WWII international legal order the United States is defending in regard to Ukraine.
In essence, a candidate should issue a call for consistency. The candidate can note how U.S. support for the Israeli and Moroccan occupations makes it difficult to win greater international support for standing up to Russian aggression. By objecting to U.S. support for Morocco’s occupation along with Israel’s occupations, it would again underscore that Israel is not being singled out and show that the candidate opposes any and all flagrant violations of the UN Charter and other international legal principles.
As is true when taking any political position, it is important to understand how these positions are met by the American public. The vast majority of Americans believe the Israeli occupation must end, and it is important to highlight that we have this support for our positions.
Topic 5: Recognizing the State of Palestine as well as the State of Israel
Talking point 5: An important principled and politically popular position would be to support the recognition of the State of Palestine alongside Israel. One hundred and fifty-seven of the 193 United Nations member states have recognized Palestine, including most of the closest allies of the United States.
Backlash claim: Most Republicans oppose the longstanding international consensus for a two-state solution, insisting that Israeli Jews inherently have more rights than Palestinian Arabs for self-determination and that such a state would serve as a base for Hamas terrorism.
Our response: The Palestine Authority, the recognized government of the State of Palestine led by a Fatah and other moderate secular groups, has long recognized Israel and renounced terrorism. Hamas, which controls less than one-third of the Gaza Strip, is a rebel faction which has not been part of the Palestinian government since 2007 and is banned in areas controlled by the Palestine Authority. Recognizing Palestine, therefore, is not a reward for Hamas terror. Palestinian negotiators have agreed that a new Palestinian state would be effectively disarmed, with international guarantees. Claiming that one people inherently have more rights than another group that has lived on the land for many centuries is effectively racist.
Analysis: Polls show 59% of Americans, including 80% of Democrats, support recognizing Palestine and support full Palestinian membership in the United Nations. Supporting the recognition of the State of Palestine alongside Israel would therefore be a popular position.
While the Democratic Party’s position formally supports a two-state solution, current policy is to only recognize the State of Israel. The Democratic National Committee has thus far blocked efforts to recognize Palestine as well. The Democratic Party leadership has long insisted that Palestinian statehood can only come through direct bilateral negotiations with Israel under terms agreed to by Israel, despite the fact that there have been no such talks for more than a decade and the Israeli government categorically rules out withdrawal from the occupied territories or recognizing a Palestinian state. It is unfair to subjugate the legitimate aspirations of a people for a state to the wishes of another state. The United States did not demand the Palestinians or Arab states agree to Israeli statehood before the United States became the first country to recognize Israel in 1948. Palestinians deserve a state, a principle of freedom that cannot be contingent on how some Israelis feel about it.
Further, U.S. policy under both Republican and Democratic administrations has been to oppose pressuring the Israeli government to compromise in any way, be it through conditioning arms transfers, through actions by the United Nations, or global civil society campaigns like boycotts, divestment, and sanctions. Effectively, this turns the leadership of both parties into opponents of Palestinian statehood.
A principled, legally-sound, and politically popular position, then, would be to call for U.S. recognition of the State of Palestine alongside Israel.
PART III
Seven More Talking Points Responding to
Controversial Terms and Phrases
Candidates are often asked to comment on terms and phrases used by some advocates of the Palestinian cause. Here are ideas for responses.
1: Apartheid
Talking point 6: Israel practices “a form of apartheid.”
Backlash claim: Apartheid is a term referring to the extreme separation of the races and the denial of citizenship rights as practiced during white minority in South Africa. This is in sharp contrast to Israel, where Arab citizens of Israel have the right to vote.
Our response: There is a growing international legal consensus that Israel is guilty of the crime of apartheid as defined by Article 7 of the 2002 Rome Statute through its discrimination, separate laws, restrictions of movement, and other policies towards the Palestinians, particularly but not exclusively in the occupied territories. The vast majority of Palestinians under Israeli control do not have the most basic political and legal rights and, even within Israel, there are close to 100 laws differentiating between Jewish and Arab citizens.
Analysis: Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have confirmed that Israel has imposed an apartheid system. Adding further credibility to the claim, Israeli groups such as B’Tselem, Adalah, Breaking the Silence, Gisha, Yesh Din, and Physicians for Human Rights-Israel agree that Israel has imposed apartheid. However, since apartheid is commonly associated with how it was practiced under white minority rule in South Africa, to avoid claims that one is saying Israel has imposed an identical system, it is probably best to say that Israel practices “a form of apartheid.”
2: Genocide
Talking point 7: While it is in no way comparable to the Holocaust, Israel is violating the Genocide Treaty and waging a genocidal war.
Backlash Claim: Since Israel could have wiped out Gaza quickly yet did not, and since Israel has not declared formal intent to commit genocide, such use of the word in relation to Israel is wrong.
Our response: “Genocide” is one of those rare words where the legal definition is broader than the popular definition. There is an increasing consensus that Israel has been committing genocide in Gaza as defined by the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. This convention was ratified by 153 countries—including the United States and Israel. It defines genocide as largescale violence that targets individuals because of their membership of a group. Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, B’Tselem, and most leading genocide scholars recognize that Israel is in violation of the Genocide Treaty. To qualify as “genocide,” actions do not require the systematic killing of everyone in that group or a formal declaration of intent. It is worth noting that this is not the only ongoing genocidal war (e.g. there are also Myanmar and Darfur), nor is it the first genocide in which the United States has supported the perpetrator and denied a genocide was taking place (e.g., Pakistan in Bangladesh in 1971; the Guatemala junta against indigenous peoples during the early 1980s; and Indonesia against East Timor during its occupation between 1975 and 1999.)
Analysis: If pressed for a yes or no answer, it would be fair to acknowledge Israel is committing genocide, though using the phrase “violating the Genocide Treaty” or “waging a genocidal war” may reduce the chances of being accused of comparing it to the Holocaust.
3: “From the River to the Sea”
Talking point 8: The term is not inherently antisemitic but it is unnecessarily triggering and should be avoided.
Backlash claim: The meaning of the phrase calling for a Free Palestine “from the River to the Sea,” a phrase adopted by Hamas, is about killing or expelling Israeli Jews and is therefore obviously antisemitic.
Our response: The origins of the phrase pre-date Hamas. The phrase calling for a Free Palestine “from the River to the Sea” was originally used by secular Palestinian nationalists in the 1960s calling for the dissolution of the state of Israel in favor of a democratic secular state with equal rights between Jews and Arabs. The slogan was not adopted by Hamas until 2018, and they have used it to convey a very different vision—that of an Islamic state without such rights for religious minorities. To say that “River to the Sea” is antisemitic because Hamas appropriated it is as disingenuous as claiming “Slava Ukraine” is fascist because it has been adopted by the Ukrainian far right. Studies have shown that most Americans who use the slogan are referring to the more inclusive interpretation of a single democratic state with equal rights Jews for Palestinians and others.
Analysis: However, due to the ways in which much of the public have been convinced that it means the killing or expulsion of Israeli Jews, it would be best to adopt a position similar to that articulated by New York mayor Zohran Mamdani and mentioned in the talking point: recognizing it is not inherently antisemitic while discouraging its use as unnecessarily triggering.
Whether one supports a two-state solution (the politically-safer choice) or a single binational state, the key principle that must be upheld is equality.
Unfortunately, since a single binational state would mean there would no longer be a Jewish state, this position is often depicted by Republicans as the desire to “destroy Israel.”
The official position of the State of Palestine and Palestinian public opinion is still in support of a two-state solution. So, even if such a single democratic secular state may have an appeal, it probably doesn’t make sense to advocate for a one-state solution.
Despite the demographic changes in Israel and Palestine, a number of creative solutions have been proposed, including allowing Palestinian citizens of Israel to also be citizens of a Palestinian state and Israeli settlers maintaining their Israeli citizenship, with both subject to non-discriminatory laws of the countries in which they live and having freedom of movement between the two states.
Rather than getting bogged down in details of what a final peace settlement would look like, however, the emphasis should be on the principle of equality—whether in one state or two, both Israeli Jews and Palestinian Arabs must have equal rights and guarantees of peace and security from the international community.
4: Intifada
Talking point 9: In Arabic, the term intifada literally means “shaking off”. It can be used to refer to any popular uprising, which can include violence and terror, but can also refer to uprisings of nonviolent resistance. While it is not necessarily a call for violence and terror, its use should be avoided because of this widespread misinterpretation.
Backlash claim: Intifadas are inherently violent uprisings carried out by terrorists.
Our response: The vast majority of the more than two dozen uprisings in the Arab world that have been referred to as intifadas in recent decades were primarily popular civil resistance movements, not military campaigns or terrorist attacks. These have included the 2005 Lebanese uprising against Syrian domination of their country (“intifada isqitlal”) and various pro-democracy struggles against Arab dictatorships. The first Palestinian intifada in the late 1980s, despite the iconic image of stone-throwing youth and the murder of some suspected collaborators, was overwhelmingly nonviolent, focusing on strikes, boycotts, alternative institutions, and other forms of nonviolent action. By contrast, the second Palestinian intifada in the early 2000s included widespread acts of terrorism which should be categorically condemned, but that does not define the term.
Analysis: Saying “Globalize the Intifada!” therefore, is essentially the same as saying “Globalize the Resistance!” However, given that many Americans associate the term with the second Palestinian intifada of a quarter century ago, which included heinous acts of terrorism, one can emphasize, as stated above, that while it is not necessarily a call for violence and terror, the term should similarly be avoided because of this widespread misinterpretation.
5: Anti-Zionism
Talking point 10: It is probably best not to have an explicit position for or against Zionism.
Backlash claim: Anti-Zionism is antisemitic.
Our response: Some forms of anti-Zionism can indeed be antisemitic (such as treating Zionism as a monolith representing its most extreme and racist manifestations or exaggerating Zionist political or financial influence in a manner paralleling historic anti-Jewish tropes.) Anti-Zionism itself is not, however. Jewishness is a religious and ethnic identity. Zionism is an ideology. While there are problems inherent in any state’s legal and political system being based upon a particular ethno-nationalist identity, the focus should be on universal principles of human rights and international law—as well as the long-term interests of Palestinians, Israelis, and U.S. security.
Analysis: Zionism has elements of both a national liberation movement of a historically-oppressed people and a colonial-settler enterprise. Since Zionism means different things to different people, it is probably wise to avoid taking a public position for or against Zionism. Since Zionism is not monolithic, it would be important avoid staking out a particular ideological position on it.
6: “Beholden to AIPAC”
Talking point 11: The American-Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) and allied PACs are supporting many Republican and some Democratic candidates, contrary to the views of most Americans, but these candidates are primarily taking their positions under their own free will and being rewarded for it, not being forced to do so.
Backlash claim: Those calling out funding by AIPAC are antisemitic.
Our response: There is nothing inherently antisemitic about criticizing an opponent for taking money from rightwing PACs allied to a foreign government.
Analysis: Results from some recent Democratic primaries have indicated that support by AIPAC and related political action committees ended up politically hurting Democratic candidates who received such support more than the additional campaign funding helped them.
Nonetheless, it would be wrong to assert that AIPAC support is a causal factor for any candidate’s militaristic positions that flagrantly disregard human rights and international law.
It is best to not accuse an opponent of supporting Israel due to funding from AIPAC and other rightwing Zionist groups, even if it might have some merit at least part in some cases. It is important not to deny candidates agency regarding their own hawkish stances. PACs tend to support candidates who agree with their positions rather than forcing candidates to do so. They are not, therefore, “controlled by AIPAC.” Rather than risk charges of promoting antisemitic conspiracy theories that exaggerate the power of wealthy Jews to dictate policy positions to candidates, it is more effective to simply note that opponents are taking a militaristic position in flagrant disregard for human rights and international law—and to point out this is contrary to the majority view of Americans.
7: BDS—boycotts, divestment, and sanctions
Talking point 12: Boycotts, divestment, and sanctions are a legitimate nonviolent and powerful means of challenging the Israeli occupation and other Israeli policies which deny legitimate rights of Palestinians. That doesn’t mean we endorse every element of the 2005 BDS Call by Palestinian civil society groups.
Our support of BDS can be especially important given its historic record of success in other campaigns over the long term.
Backlash claim: BDS parallels historic boycotts of Jewish businesses and institutions that were antisemitic; therefore, BDS tactics are antisemitic.
Our response: BDS are legitimate nonviolent tactics which have been utilized under different names in support of a variety of human rights struggles over the years. This includes against the Israeli government and corporate interests that support its violations of human rights and international law. The right to boycott has long been recognized as legitimate free speech; state and federal efforts to punish those advocating BDS and related campaigns demanding corporate responsibility are wrong.
Analysis: In 2005, the Palestinian Civil Society Call for BDS was launched by a coalition of over 170 Palestinian unions, women’s groups, refugee networks, and professional associations. One can support certain aspects of the BDS Call (e.g., boycotting corporations which directly support illegal Israeli settlements, the Israeli occupation, or ongoing Israeli war crimes) and not others (e.g., opposing collaborative Jewish-Arab projects promoting peace, boycotting Israeli academic institutions.)
The tactics of boycotts and divestment have been part of campaigns to put pressure on multinational corporations to end their illegal profiting off foreign occupations. These tactics are particularly important in cases where the United States or other powers have blocked the United Nations from enforcing resolutions calling for withdrawal of occupation forces. In previous decades, boycott and divestment campaigns targeted companies supporting South Africa’s occupation of Namibia and Indonesia’s occupation of East Timor. A campaign is currently underway, particularly strong in Europe, that supports BDS against the Moroccan occupation of Western Sahara.
Part of the opposition to BDS may stem from an unspoken concern: the tactic is effective. Proponents of Israeli policies don’t want the campaigns to spread, as they have many times throughout history. There is a long and celebrated history of boycotts in the United States. Boycotts targeted British goods during America’s independence struggle and targeted products made by enslaved people during the abolitionist struggle; more recent campaigns have focused on ending segregation, sweatshops, exploitation of migrant farmworkers, and more.
Sanctions also have a storied history. To cite but a few examples, the United States and other countries have imposed them on Russia for its illegal occupation and annexation of Ukrainian territory. They also did so back in 1990 in response to Iraq’s illegal occupation and annexation of Kuwait.
In addition, there was the large-scale BDS campaign in the 1970s and 1980s against South Africa, demanding that the country end its apartheid system and allow for majority rule. Other recent BDS campaigns have targeted Burma, Sudan, and other countries engaged in notorious human rights violations.
Anti-BDS efforts are led not just by pro-Israel groups, but also by corporate interests; recognizing the effectiveness of previous BDS campaigns, they are seeking to undermine campaigns demanding corporate responsibility, including those supporting labor rights, fighting climate change, and promoting racial and economic justice. The legitimacy of boycotts, divestment, and sanctions as a tactic is an important principle to defend, which goes well beyond the question of Israel and Palestine.
Part IV
Conclusion:
Advocate “tough love” for Israel,
call for universal values,
and proclaim the moral role the U.S. should play
The vast majority of Americans—not just progressive Democrats—believe that it is wrong to support any government engaging in war crimes. Opposing Israeli policies and U.S. support for them is not being “anti-Israel.” Indeed, progressive candidates could consider using the term “tough love,” arguing that while Israeli Jews fully deserve peace and security and the United States could be a guarantor of that right, Washington must not continue to provide a blank check for a far-right Israeli government engaging in illegal, immoral, racist, and self-destructive policies. Some have used the analogy of a drunkard stumbling from a bar with the car keys in their hand. A real friend takes the keys away so they will not hurt themselves or others. Perhaps more accurately, the United States is the bartender —the enabler—who is continuing to provide the means for dangerous, irresponsible, and criminal behavior.
It is important to de-exceptionalize the debate on Israel/Palestine to make clear how any attack from opponents accusing us of “singling out Israel” is unfair U.S. foreign policy should be rooted in human rights across the board. Similarly, just as domestic law must be applied consistently regardless of the alleged perpetrator’s political leanings, so it is with international law.
Most Americans do not believe that the lives and the aspirations of one people are any less valuable than those of others. Killing civilians is wrong, whether by irregular armed groups labeled as terrorists or by nation states. Invading, occupying, and colonizing neighboring countries is wrong, regardless of the perpetrator’s ideology, ethnicity, religion, or geopolitical alignment. Voters find such forthrightness helpful in assessing candidates.
In short, let’s emphasize our stance is not about Israel per se. This is about the role the United States should be playing in the world. The United States has continued to support Israel in the face of its horrific crimes not because of the power of AIPAC to persuade the U.S. to do so, but for the same the reasons it has supported other rightwing allies engaged in horrific crimes for decades.
Just as most Americans oppose war crimes, most voters believe it is wrong to support a government engaged in the mass killing of civilians and the colonization of occupied lands. As mentioned in an earlier talking point, what Israel is doing would be just as wrong as if any other country did it. And it would be just as wrong to provide any other government engaging in such crimes with the military, financial, and diplomatic support that the US currently provides to Israel.
The more our focus can be on upholding basic moral and legal principles rather than on ideological battles, the more likely a progressive candidate will find Israel/Palestine a winning issue.
