In the wake of 9/11, I was one of many analysts and activists concerned that the possible U.S. reaction to the heinous criminal act could make the situation far worse. In recounting my own story and participation in the national debate, I aim to demonstrate how predicting the tragic outcomes was based on understanding why that attacks took place and the context in which U.S. power was perceived, a context we would do well to keep in mind today when we assess U.S. actions throughout the world.
Twenty-five years ago today, I was awoken here on the west coast by a call from Martha Honey at the Institute for Policy Studies in Washington, DC. I’d been working closely with her and her colleagues for Foreign Policy in Focus, where I served as Middle East editor. She had told me that a plane had crashed into one of the World Trade Center towers. Initially I wasn’t that concerned. I knew that a plane had crashed into the Empire State Building during a thick fog sixty years earlier that didn’t do much damage. I turned on the television and noticed that it was a bright sunny day and that it was clearly not an accident. I also soon realized that it was a much larger plane with a lot more flammable fuel, resulting in an extremely hot fire that threatened the integrity of the structure. I then saw the second plane fly into the other tower, and, not long afterwards, both towers collapsing.
I soon started getting media calls. I immediately suspected Al Qaeda, but didn’t want to speculate. A couple of days later it became apparent that indeed it was. The next few days were filled with scores of interviews—even with Fox News. (Fortunately, I had just begun my first sabbatical at the University of San Francisco, and I didn’t have to worry about teaching.) Among the media questions was “why do they hate us?” I challenged the prevailing view that it was because they “hate our freedom.” I noted that, while I was as proud of our democratic institutions and individual liberties as any American, the reality is that U.S. policy in the Middle East has had very little to do with freedom and democracy. I also observed how people in the Middle East generally did not see our freedom and democracy at work, but they did see “Made in USA” on spent tear gas canisters and bomb casings.
I noted that Al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden didn’t know much about Islam, but as a former businessman, he knew how to take a grievance and manipulate it to sell a product. This is why none of his manifestos attacks American freedom, since most of the world’s Muslims would like more freedom. Instead, he talked about U.S. policy in the Middle East, which most Muslims opposed.
I argued, therefore, that we were hated not because of values but because we had strayed from those values. If we had a policy based more on human rights, international law and sustainable development and less on military conquest and occupation, arms transfers, and protecting the profits of oil companies and other multinational corporations, it would not only be more consistent with our stated values, but we would also be a lot safer.
In short, I argued that we must recognize that our greatest strength was not in our powerful weaponry and far-flung military might, but in the fortitude, the caring, and the noble values of the American people.
Immediately, Sean Hannity and other Fox News commentators started claiming I was blaming the United States for the tragedy and justifying the attacks. My university was deluged with calls demanding that I be fired. I found this rather bizarre. By way of analogy, when detectives investigate a murder, one of the things they look for is motive. That doesn’t mean those detectives are justifying the murder. Likewise, my discussion of the killers’ motivations was not a justification for terrorism. The goal of my critics was to stifle any kind of introspection that might lead to a change in policy. Meanwhile, at the other end of this crazy spectrum, an article that posited 9/11 was some kind of vast conspiracy of the U.S. government, accused me and Noam Chomsky of being “gatekeepers of Empire” for acknowledging that Al-Qaeda was indeed responsible.
One of the hard things about the 9/11 tragedy for me was that I did not have the opportunity to grieve because I was so worried about how the United States would react. Unfortunately, my fears were justified.
I wrote a series of newspaper op-eds (as well as ghostwriting one for Harry Belafonte) calling for a decisive but calculated response. I was asked to do a commentary for “All Things Considered,” and recorded it at my local NPR affiliate. But NPR’s editors in Washington nixed it. USA Today published my most widely circulated piece entitled “Don’t Bomb Afghanistan.” I argued that while a targeted military paramilitary operation targeted bin Laden and the Al Qaeda leadership was justifiable, high-altitude bombing of an impoverished and already war-ravaged country was not the way to destroy a clandestine network of underground terrorist cells. In particular, I argued that sending ground forces into Afghanistan would get us bogged down in years of tribal warfare in hostile terrain. There is a version of that piece here.
As the Bush administration demanded Congress authorize a military response, the only Congressional office to contact me was that of Rep. Barbara Lee. I advised her against voting for the authorization of force because the language was too broad and it could be used to bog us down in endless wars in the region. I have no idea whether I had any impact, but she was the only member of Congress to vote no.
Bush and other American political leaders claimed that going to war was a test of our resolve. I argued that demonstrating resolve was unnecessary: extremists in the Middle East had no doubts regarding America’s military strength. The weakness they perceived concerned America’s moral strength. Millions of people in the Middle East and beyond believed that it was morally wrong for the United States to support Arab dictatorships and Israeli occupation forces. They believed it was morally wrong that the amount of U.S. military aid to the Middle East was six times that of its economic aid. They believed it was morally wrong that the #1 U.S. export to the region was not consumer goods, high-tech equipment, or agricultural products, but armaments. They believed it was morally wrong for the United States to bomb and impose deadly sanctions against Iraq.
Within a couple months, I published my first book, Tinderbox: US Middle East Policy and the Roots of Terrorism, in which I made the case that the more the United States had militarized the Middle East, the less secure we had become.
All of these problems I articulated at the time have only worsened subsequently, most of them exacerbated by bipartisan action in Washington.
Indeed, no one was happier than Osama bin Laden that the U.S. implemented the policies it subsequently pursued, particularly the invasion of Iraq. Political leaders from Dick Cheney to Hillary Clinton falsely claimed that Saddam Hussein had operational ties to Al Qaeda, even though they hated each other. Saddam brutally suppressed Islamists in Iraq and Bin Laden considered Saddam an apostate, infidel, and a traitor to Islam. We warned that invading Iraq would distract from the fight against Al Qaeda. We warned that the reaction to an invasion, occupation, and repressive counter-insurgency military campaign in the heart of the Muslim world would create even more extreme Salafist Islamist terrorists—which we saw in the rise of ISIS. The Bush administration nevertheless pursued what we told them would be an illegal, unnecessary, and disastrous war. Unfortunately, they were supported by such prominent Democrats as Joe Biden, Chuck Schumer, John Kerry, Hillary Clinton, and Adam Schiff, among others.
The 9/11 tragedy was the beginning of my role as a frequent media analyst and public speaker—a pundit. While I am thankful to have an audience, it appears that those who actually have political power remain dismissive of the warnings I and others have subsequently given about Iran, Yemen, Israel/Palestine, and other tragedies. Indeed, the United States is still pursuing the same policies that created the reaction that led to the rise of Al Qaeda and the deaths of nearly 3,000 Americans in that tragedy 25 years ago.
On this anniversary, let’s mourn the dead. And let’s also resolve to fight like hell to change the policies that contributed to that tragic day 25 years ago and to many more since then.
